Hybrid, Plug-in Hybrid, or Fully Electric Car - Which Should You Get?




This Kia Sorento plug-in hybrid is a great alternative to an all-electric car

Gas prices are going up. But don’t just rush into getting a new car if you already have a car with a loan. If you have negative equity in your current car, keeping it might be the better financial decision. The longer you keep your current car, the less it will cost you in the long run versus trading it in.

Also, if you own your current car outright, keeping it might save money in the long run. Too often, motorists look at short-term gains or just want to rid themselves of the emotional baggage of paying high gas prices. Like most commodities, gas prices fluctuate based on many local, seasonal, and global factors. Getting a new car with a loan means you will be paying $600 or more each month, every month for 3 - 5 years. Add the cost of that up and then compare it with your monthly gasoline expense. 

By the way, if you're considering a new car and the payment is around $1,000 per month or more, you need to find a lower-priced car.

One thing I’ve noticed repeatedly is that people who trade in larger cars or trucks for a small economy car are usually not happy in the long term. Usually, the payment goes up, but they're getting "less car" with that newer, smaller car.  Then, they flip the car again, adding to their debt. This is one way consumers end up with $1200 car payments.

Still, there are some excellent new and used hybrid SUVs, and that might be a good compromise. Same with a used electric car, those are reasonably priced and use no gas. Besides, most EVs have a generous warranty 


Here are key differences and similarities among electric vehicles (EVs), plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), and hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs).


1. Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs)


By definition, EVs are fully powered by electricity; EVs use a large battery pack and an electric motor with no gasoline engine. If you don't charge it up, it won't go. Sometimes, these are called Battery Electric Vehicles (BEV) or just "EV."


Pros:

  • No exhaust comes from the car, like with a gas-powered car
  • Lower maintenance costs due to fewer moving parts
  • Often qualify for federal and state incentives (this is regional)
  • Quick and quiet driving experience
Cons: 
  • Inconvenient for some drivers
  • Expensive initial purchase price
  • You will want to install a home charger
  • Rapid depreciation 

Examples:

  • Tesla Model 3 RWD (2026): $40,000 or a little less, range - 320+ miles
  • Chevrolet Bolt (2026): $30,000, range - 262 miles
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E Select (2025): $39,995, EPA range - 250+ miles
  • Hyundai IONIQ 9 (2026) - $60,000, EPA range - 335 miles 

2. Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEVs)


PHEVs combine a gasoline engine with a rechargeable battery for short all-electric driving (typically 20–50 miles) and long-range hybrid operation after the battery is depleted.


Pros:

  • Can drive on electric power for daily commutes and short trips
  • Gasoline backup for long trips, reducing range anxiety
  • Potential tax incentives similar to EVs
Cons: 
  • More expensive to purchase 
  • Need to plug in to get the best MPG results

Examples:

  • Toyota RAV4 Plug-in Hybrid (2026): $43,000, 52-mile electric range, 107 MPGe combined, 41 - 44 MPG hybrid mode.
  • Hyundai Tucson Plug-In Hybrid (2026): $41,000, 30-mile electric range, 77 MPGe combined, 35 MPG hybrid mode.
  • Kia Sorento PHEV (2026): $50,000, 32-mile electric range, 74 MPGe combined, 33 MPG hybrid model.

3. Hybrid Electric Vehicles (HEVs)


Definition: Use a smaller battery and electric motor to assist a gasoline engine; it cannot be plugged in. The combination adds up to great fuel economy. 


Pros:

  • Excellent fuel economy without charging
  • Lower upfront cost than PHEVs or EVs
  • Proven reliability and technology
Cons:
  • Often more expensive than a gasoline-only vehicle 

Examples:

  • Toyota Camry (2026): $31,000, 51 MPG (all new Camrys are hybrid)
  • Honda Accord Hybrid (2026): $35,000, 49 MPG 
  • Ford Maverick Hybrid (2026): $30,000, 39 MPG 

The Ford Maverick is likely the most affordable, most versatile, most "common sense" new vehicle you can get today. 


Key Differences for BEV, HEV, PHEV:

Feature

EV

PHEV

HEV

Fuel Source

Electricity only

Electricity + Gas

Gasoline + electricity 

(makes its own electricity)

Electric Only Range

200–400+ miles

20–50 miles

<2 miles (assist only and low-speed driving)

Charging Required

Yes

Optional

No

Purchase Price

High

Moderate

Low 

Total Driving Range

250 - 500 miles

500+ miles

400 - 600+ miles 


Summary:

  • BEVs are best for zero-emission driving (when emissions are measured at the car) and for lower operating costs, but they require home or public charging. BEVs are also more expensive to buy new. 
  • PHEVs offer a bridge, kinda like the best of both worlds, with short EV-only trips and gas for flexibility. Frequent charging delivers the best results. 
  • HEVs provide the simplest efficiency boost, requiring no charging.

Budget, charging access, and daily driving distance will determine which type is the best fit.


In most regions of the U.S., a used BEV will be the best 


-Brian Moody


Learn more about fully electric cars and their advantages and disadvantages.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Costco Gas Along Interstate 5 - LA to SF

Image
Did you know Costco gas is sometimes .15 cents cheaper than regular name brand gas? That's kind of a lot - shop on a major interstate like I-5 and the price difference can be even more dramatic. The problem is, most Costcos are near city centers or shopping area - not really ideal for the highway traveler. So here's a few you can easily find on the road from LA to SF. There's a new Costco in Lakewood, CA right behind the Lakewood Center Mall. It's not really freeway close but about 2 miles East off the 605 Fwy or 2 miles South of the 91 Fwy. The address is 340 Lakewood Center Mall. Just North of Los Angeles the Pacoima Costco is very near the 118 Fwy. If you use the 210 to get to I-5, this one is perfect. It's located at 13550 W Paxton in Pacoima. Travel North out of LA on I-5 and the Costco's get pretty slim. If you need gas just outside the Grapvine, take 99 instead of I-5 for a few miles. The speed limit is still 70 here so you won't lose much time. The S...
Read more

If You Really Want to Use Less Gas...

Image
If people are serious about using less gas and fewer resources, then just drive something used like this - the 2012 Mazda5 is a six-passenger minivan that gets 28 miles per gallon on the highway.  By the way, a new $45,000 Toyota Highlander Hybrid gets 35 miles per gallon in mixed highway/city driving. In the Mazda5, I was able to get 24 mpg in combined city and highway driving. The Mazda5 is comfortable, fun to drive, and versatile - plus, it costs about $7,000 used. Maybe you don't need a new hybrid or electric car. It's a similar story with cars like the Ford Focus, Chevy Cruze, Honda Fit, Ford Fiesta, and Kia Sportage.
Read more

Mercury Messenger - Ford, Please Build This Car

Image
Here's the last Mercury that was really worth getting excited about - sure the Milan is OK but imagine a Mercury that people under 70 would buy. Sort of like a modern Cougar (let's just pretend the late 90s Cougar never happened). Since this was a concept, details are scant. The idea was to build a sort of Mustang but with the luxury of a Mercury. Under the hood is a 4.6 liter V8 - 300 hp isn't out of the question. As Mercury continues to languish I can't help but think fondly of Mercurys of the recent and distant past. If you like the Messenger, here's a bunch of cool pics.
Read more